Batard-Montrachet(Sep 2003): not oxidised [WK Choy]
Batard-Montrachet(Dec 2010): oxidised
Batard-Montrachet(07 Jul 2005): not oxidized, quite tight and youtfhful [Don Cornwell]
Batard-Montrachet(28 Feb 2007): not oxidized – see related tasting notes [Don Cornwell]
Batard-Montrachet (Mar 2015): not oxidized - showing well [J. Poell]
Batard-Montrachet (Nov 2016): Showing pronounced signs of tiring, deepish gold, very honeyed, marked acidity but not well integrated. Drinkable but well
past its best. [K. Lamb]
Bienvenues-Batard Montrachet(Aug 2004): not oxidised [WK Choy]
Bienvenues-Batard-Montrachet(17 Nov 2005): no oxidation [G Deschamps]
Bienvenues-Batard-Montrachet(Jan-Mar 2007): no oxidation and brilliant, but utterly open and ready to drink. Extremely odd and inconsistent behavior for a young Ramonet grand cru, and to my mind indicative of 1st stage of oxidation to come. Drink over next year or two while the wine is stunning. [J. Gilman]
Bienvenues-Batard-Montrachet(Oct 2011): Not oxidized. Delightful, if not a bit austere. Perhaps safe from the pre- premox phase that J. Gilman noted for his. [NTyson]
Bienvenues-Batard-Montrachet (Oct 2012): Not oxidized, has lost all charm [ER]
Chassagne(Oct 2008): no oxidation. A 375ml bottle of AOC wine, yet nothing more than “age-appropriate” color, aromas and flavors. Really quite nice for what it is. [David Honig]
Chassagne Boudriottes(Sep 2004-Dec 2005): 6 bottles. None oxidised [WK Choy]
Chassagne Boudriottes(Jan 2007): not oxidized, excellent (Odd Rydland)
Chassagne Boudriottes(Dec 2006): Slightly oxidized (Steinar Midttømme)
Chassagne Boudriottes(Dec 2006): Not oxidized (Steinar Midttømme)
Chassagne Boudriottes(25 Apr 2008): not oxidised, but corked, as it happens [Jan-Tore Egge]
Chassagne Boudriottes(22 May 2008): not oxidised; beautiful wine [Jan-Tore Egge]
Chassagne Caillerets(May 2006): forward and mature, showing signs of fraying and lack of grip and length on finish. Again, early signs of premature oxidation. Drink soon. (J. Gilman)
Chassagne Caillerets(May 2007): no signs of oxidation (ER)
Chassagne Caillerets(Jan 2010): Perfectly balanced, no signs of oxidation. [AT Bridge]
Chassagne Caillerets(July 2007) oxidized (R DeAngelo)
Chassagne Morgeot(Jul 2005): Tasted four times, one oxidized [Steinar Midttømme]
Chassagne Ruchottes(Aug 2004-Oct 2005): 2 bottles. Neither oxidised [WK Choy]
Chassagne Ruchottes(Dec 2005): not oxidised [WK Choy]
Chassagne Ruchottes(Nov 2006): No signs of oxidation, but very forward and a point on the nose; palate softening and beginning to lose grip on the finish- 1st stage premature oxidation. (J. Gilman)
Chassagne Ruchottes(28 Feb. 2007): by consensus, partially oxidized–see related 1999 tasting notes [Don Cornwell]
Chassagne Ruchottes(Jan-Feb 2009): 2 out of 3 bottles oxidized and completely shot; the 3rd (and my last) amazingly young and fresh [MSaviage]
Chassagne Ruchottes(June 2009): Not oxidized but very ready to go and getting quite soft. [Mike Klein]
Chassagne Ruchottes(Jan 2012): oxidized [ER]
Chassagne Ruchottes(May 2012): Not oxidized–fantastic bottle. [AT Bridge]
Chassagne Vergers(July 2008) no oxidation, very good [Dale Williams]
Chassagne Vergers (Dec 2016) not oxidized (R DeAngelo)
Chevalier Montrachet(10 Dec 2008) not oxidized; amazing wine [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier Montrachet(August 2009): Not oxidized, brilliant wine. [AT Bridge]
Chevalier Montrachet(August 2008): Not oxidized. [AT Bridge]
Chevalier Montrachet(April 2011): Not oxidized, fabulous wine [Alan Weinberg]
Chevalier Montrachet(May 2011): another fabulous bottle [Alan Weinberg]
Montrachet(17 Nov 2005): no oxidation [G Deschamps]
Montrachet(5 Mar 2007): no oxidation; awesome wine – see related 1999 tasting notes [Don Cornwell]
Montrachet(July 2009): Not oxidised. Cork did not appear blue. [WK Choy]
Montrachet(August 2009): Not oxidised. [WK Choy]
Montrachet (July 2014): Oxidized. [N. Lau]
Montrachet (June 2016): Not oxidized. Full bodied, rich, silky texture…Batard in style with a pronounced minerality. (Ken Lamb)
Puligny Champs Canet(Nov 2006): Not oxidized, fresh and structured, much less advanced the Ruchottes. (J. Gilman)
(July 2009): Not oxidised. Cork did not appear blue. [WK Choy]
Puligny Champs Canet(8 Dec 2006): no oxidation [P Sidebotham]
Puligny Champs Canet (Feb 2008): no oxidation, fresh [ER]
Puligny Champs Canet (Oct 2012): fresh, excellent [ER]