Chevalier-Montrachet (07 Jul 2005): not oxidized, very youthful and awesome. Rated 95+ [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier-Montrachet (28 Feb 2007): not oxidized; again one of the best wines of the tasting –see related tasting notes [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier-Montrachet (Sep. 2008-Feb 2009): 6 additional bottles recently purchased at Acker auction–none oxidized, but every bottle more advanced than all others I've had. Three with deep mature gold color, very mature obviously advanced flavors. Two bottles were better but not at prior standards. One very good bottle, but still below prior bottles from Europe. I suspect poor storage by the prior owner. [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier Montrachet (13 May 2009): completely oxidized. Undrinkable. Poured down the drain. [AT Bridge]
Chevalier Montrachet (23 May 2009): substantially oxidized and falling apart. [David Honig]
Chevalier Montrachet (29 Nov 2009): From original stock–Not oxidized; soft, almost completely mature wine; very elegant. Drink up (I bought a lot of this, so I need to get busy.) [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier Montrachet (2 Jan 2010): From original stock: An absolutely pristine and awesome bottle [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier Montrachet (15 Feb 2010): From original stock: Very deeply colored, utterly mature but not oxidized bottle. Amazing variation. [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier Montrachet (4 Apr 2010): From original stock: not oxidized but fully mature. Drink up. [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier Montrachet (21 and 25 June 2010): From original stock: one completely oxidized, one not oxidized but mature [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier Montrachet (10 Sept 2010): From original stock: not oxidized but fully mature. Drink up. [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier Montrachet (30 Oct 2010): From original stock: not oxidized, mature. [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier Montrachet (6 Dec 2010): From Acker auction stock: partially oxidized [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier Montrachet (01 Jan 2011): not oxidized; excellent. [Thomas Küntziger]
Chevalier Montrachet (March 2013): not oxidized; superb. One of the 2 or 3 best white burgs I've ever had. (not 99 Coche CC, but not a big step behind) (Acker auction a couple years back; 99 Girardin Chevie from same lot oxidized). [Mark Preston]
Chevalier Montrachet (December 2015): Completely oxidized, deep gold color going on brown. Fruit completely gone, just a thin strip of one-dimensional something-or-other running through. Bummer. [P. Mesrobian]