“Beaune de Chateau” 1er Cru Blanc: very oxidized [Paul Ferrari]
Chablis(Feb 2006): young and fresh [Bill Nanson]
Chablis Bougros(Summer 2005): fabulous - shame they sold out [Bill Nanson]
Chevalier Montrachet(18 Feb 2010): not oxidized, truly outstanding and on this night better than the Cabotte. See 2002 Tasting Notes Night Two [Don Cornwell]
Chevalier Montrachet (Aug 2013): not oxidized [R Younger]
Chevalier Montrachet “Cabotte”(May 2008) Mid stage premox.Butterscotchy and frayed but drinkable.[Kevin Harvey]
Chevalier Montrachet “Cabotte”(Jan 2010) young and as it should be [Alan Weinberg]
Chevalier Montrachet “Cabotte”(Sept 2010) Completely oxidized
Chevalier Montrachet “Cabotte”(18 Feb 2010): excellent and not oxidized. See 2002 Tasting Notes Night Two [Don Cornwell]
Corton Charlemagne(Dec 2005 + May 2007): 2 bottles, both extremely young, but great (no oxidation) [Michael Eder]
Corton Charlemagne(Febuary 2009): Outstanding! Not oxidized [Lewis Dawson]
Corton Charlemagne(12 Mar 2009): excellent [Herwig Janssen]
Corton Charlemagne(May 2009); excellent, penetrating, all it should be [Joe Durnell]
Corton Charlemagne(June 2009): 2 bottles, also excellent,no oxidation [Joe Durnell]
Corton Charlemagne(November 2009); excellent, too young [pep]
Corton Charlemagne(4 Feb 2010): Very nice, not oxidized. See 2002 Tasting Notes Night One [Don Cornwell]
Corton Charlemagne(16 Jan 2010): Very nice, starting to come around, no hints of oxidation. [J. Floren]
Corton Charlemagne(Dec 2010): No premox, still young and where it should be at this age (MSaviage)
Corton Charlemagne(May 2011): No signs of premox - still young and fresh (MSaviage)
Corton Charlemagne( July 2011 ): 2 bottles, purchased at Domaine, tight and youthful, no oxidation ( R Younger )
Corton Charlemagne( July 2011 ): 1 bottle, still youthful, tight and fresh. (E Lundblad)
Corton Charlemagne (May 2012 ): 4 bottles, incredibly good, still crisp and full of flavor! [Bill Lawrence]
Corton Charlemagne, (June 2014): and oxidised undinkable had been stored at 12 degrees for years; Howard Hilton
Meursault Les Clous(3 Dec 2005): totally oxidized in 375mL format [David Chan]
Meursault Les Clous(July 2006) had 5 times since release, all in 750s, different cities and sources, none oxidized. [David Klinger]
Meursault Les Clous(Jan 2006): not oxidized but very forward; blue tinged cork [B. Delancy]
Meursault Les Clous(Nov 2005 - May 2007): 5 bottles, none oxidized, one perhaps a bit more advanced than it should have been [Michael Eder]
Meursault Les Clous(Apr 2009): not oxidized, very good. [Andrew Phillips]
Meursault Les Clous(Jun 2009): Premoxed - badly. [Mike Klein]
Meursault Les Clous(Apr 2009): not oxidized. [P Muto]
Meursault Genevrieres(Feb 2007): had 5 times since release, all in 750s, different cities and sources, none oxidized.[David Klinger]
Meursault Genevrieres(Mar 2006): Youthful, very good, precise [Joe Durnell]
Meursault Genevrieres(Oct 2007): Youthful, very good, [Ben Delancy]
Meursault Genevrieres(Jan. 2008): Youthful, very good [Howard Cooper]
Meursault Genevrieres(May 2009) Completely shot. Undrinkably oxidized. [Kevin Harvey]
Meursault Genevrieres(November 2009): A bit more mature than in 2008 but not oxidised [Howard Cooper
Meursault Genevrieres(28 April 2010): From magnum. Recognizably Cote d'Or, but site character is absent and the wine is cracking up. My first experience of premox (or heat damage) in a 1500ml bottle. [David Honig]
Meursault Genevrieres(18 Dec 2010): A second magnum from the same source was fresh, not oxidized and showing very well [David Honig]
Meursault Genevrieres(4 Sept 2011): Third magnum from the same source was, if anything, younger than the last one, very stony and just entering peak form. [David Honig]
Meursault Genevrieres: (March 12 2011). Total premox, DOA. [Chris Brown]
Meursault Perrières(Mar 2005): very tasty, not oxidised [Bill Nanson]
Meursault Perrieres( Mar 12 , 2005 ) : oxidized , second bottle too ( Herwig Janssen )
Meursault Perrieres( May 28, 2009 ) : totally oxidized ,undrinkable (Dale Williams )
Meursault Perrières(Jun 2009): still young color, lots of oxidative aroma and flavour though - 10 from 12 okay before this [Bill Nanson]
Meursault Perrieres(Oct 2009): med gold color is darker than you'd expect at this age; hints of premox on the nose (sweeter, lacking minerality); great intensity in the mouth, but the ingredients suggest this is getting worse, not better in the bottle (MSaviage)
Meursault Perrieres(Jan 2010): Not oxidized. Cork not bleached, lighter gold color and an excellent bottle. [Keith Akers]
Meursault Perrieres(4 Feb 2010): oxidized and undrinkable. See 2002 Tasting Notes, Night One. [Don Cornwell]
Meursault Perrieres(3 March 2010): youthful, very good. [Jake Hartinger]
Meursault Perrières(5 April 2010): completely oxidized. Undrinkable. [Eric LaMasters]
Meursault Perrieres(March 12 2011): Premox. [Chris Brown]
Meursault Perrieres (Sept 2012): No premox in this magnum-tight and still young [R Younger]
Meursault Perrieres ( April 2013) partially oxidised ( B. Henry)
Meursault Perrieres (Oct 2014) better than previous bottle above, barest hint of oxidation [b.henry]
Meursault Perrieres (Aug 2015): No premox-solid and drinking well [R Younger]
Meursault Charmes(23rd and 29th October 2010): Two bottles D. O. A. [Ralph Earle]
Montrachet(3 Mar 2010): not oxidized and quite good. See 2002 Tasting Notes, Night Three. [Don Cornwell]
Montrachet (16 Sep 2011) not oxidised, not as tight or as good as the 05. (Don Osborne)
Montrachet (August 2012): not oxidized, from half-bottle [David Kubiak]
Montrachet (Oct 2014): not oxidized. @Aquavit bday dinner [N. Lau]